From the series: When the Solution Is the Impossible
Prof. Dr. Faid Mohammed Said
Introduction: The Qur’anic Moment and the Question of the Heart
Among the Qur’anic narratives that transcend historical context and penetrate the deepest layers of human consciousness, the account of Abraham’s request to witness the revival of the dead (Qur’an 2:260) occupies a singular theological and epistemological position. It is a moment in which revelation engages not only belief, but the psychology of faith, the epistemology of certainty, and the role of the heart as a locus of knowing.
Abraham (peace be upon him), described in the Qur’an as the Khalīl—the intimate friend of God—poses a question that is neither skeptical nor defiant. It is a question that reflects the nobility of intellectual humility and spiritual maturity:
“My Lord, show me how You give life to the dead.”
This request is not a challenge to divine power, but a yearning for inner reassurance—an ascent from affirmed belief to lived certainty.
Faith Beyond Doubt: Why Abraham Asked “How”
Crucially, Abraham does not ask whether God resurrects the dead. That truth is already firmly established within his faith. Instead, he asks how—a question oriented toward understanding, not denial.
The Qur’anic dialogue that follows is profoundly instructive. God asks, “Do you not believe?”—not as reproach, but as affirmation. Abraham replies, “Yes, but so that my heart may be reassured.”
Here, the Qur’an articulates a foundational theological insight: faith (īmān) is not a static condition but a dynamic continuum. One may possess full doctrinal belief while still seeking a deeper state of inner tranquility (ṭumaʾnīnah).
This moment establishes a critical distinction between intellectual assent and existential reassurance. Abraham’s faith was complete, yet his heart sought elevation—from ʿilm al-yaqīn (knowledge-based certainty) to ʿayn al-yaqīn (certainty through direct witnessing).
Divine Pedagogy: From Propositional Knowledge to Witnessed Truth
God’s response to Abraham does not take the form of abstract explanation or metaphysical argument. Instead, it manifests as a divinely orchestrated experiential demonstration.
Abraham is instructed to take four birds, dismember them, scatter their parts across distant mountains, and then call them back. What follows is not merely resurrection, but response—movement, return, and reassembly.
This method reflects a distinct Qur’anic epistemology: truth is not only taught, it is shown. Knowledge is not confined to propositions but is embodied in signs (āyāt) enacted within reality itself.
The choice of birds is symbolically significant. Birds represent dispersion, movement, and vitality. Their fragmentation and reconstitution communicate a clear theological message: divine power gathers what has been scattered, restores what has been lost, and revives what has died—regardless of distance or disintegration.
The Impossible as a Theological Category
Within the broader Qur’anic landscape, many miracles transform dire circumstances: seas part, fire cools, water springs forth, and infertility gives way to life. The resurrection of the birds, however, confronts a deeper boundary—death itself.
Here, the “impossible” is not merely exceeded; it is redefined. Divine action is shown not as intervention within natural laws, but as sovereignty over them. The narrative affirms that impossibility is a human category, not a divine one.
Thus, within the logic of this series, this episode represents the apex of the theme: God does not merely change circumstances—He transcends the very framework within which circumstances are understood.
Certainty (Yaqīn) in Islamic Epistemology
Classical Islamic epistemology is fundamentally integrative. Knowledge is derived through a convergence of:
• Revelation (waḥy)
• Reason (ʿaql)
• Witnessing and experience (mushāhadah)
The Abrahamic narrative occupies the precise intersection of these modes. Revelation had already affirmed resurrection; reason had already accepted it. What remained was existential certainty—knowledge that settles not only the mind but the heart.
This aligns with the Qur’anic hierarchy of certainty:
• ʿIlm al-yaqīn
• ʿAyn al-yaqīn
• Ḥaqq al-yaqīn
Abraham’s request marks a transition within this hierarchy, without negating any prior level.
The Heart (Qalb) as an Epistemic Center
One of the most profound implications of this narrative is its affirmation of the heart as a center of knowing. The Qur’an repeatedly associates understanding with the heart, not merely the intellect.
Abraham’s concern was not cognitive doubt but inner reassurance. This situates ṭumaʾnīnah as a legitimate epistemic aim. In Islamic theology, knowledge that fails to produce serenity, humility, and trust is considered incomplete.
Thus, the narrative challenges modern reductions of knowledge to rationalism or empiricism alone and affirms a holistic epistemology integrating mind, heart, and lived experience.
Omnipotence, Causality, and the Suspension of Natural Law
From a theological perspective, the resurrection of the birds reinforces the Islamic understanding of divine omnipotence (qudrah). Classical Sunni theology maintains that causal laws are customary patterns, not binding necessities.
Miracles, therefore, are not violations of reason but manifestations of a higher order of causality. God does not operate within nature alone; He governs it.
This positions the Qur’anic worldview in contrast with deistic or naturalistic frameworks, wherein divine action is constrained by immutable natural law.
Contemporary Reflections: Reassurance in an Age of Epistemic Anxiety
In an age marked by fragmentation, skepticism, and existential uncertainty, the Abrahamic model offers profound relevance. It affirms that seeking reassurance is not weakness, that questioning can coexist with faith, and that divine wisdom remains operative even when human understanding collapses.
What appears irreparably broken can be reassembled. What seems impossible can become the very path through which certainty is deepened.
Conclusion: When the Impossible Becomes the Path to God
The Qur’an concludes this narrative with the declaration: “Know that God is Almighty, All-Wise.” Power is thus inseparable from wisdom, and divine action from purpose.
The story of Abraham and the birds stands as a paradigmatic example of Islamic reflective theology—integrating revelation, reason, experience, and inner tranquility.
When the solution lies beyond human possibility, certainty is no longer sought in outcomes, but in God Himself.
Skip to content